India: Three right to information activists murdered
Event- Country
- India
- Initial Date
- May 26, 2010
- Final Date
- Aug 27, 2010
- Event Description
In May, July and August 2010, three Right to Information (RTI) activists were murdered. On 26 May 2010, Datta Patil was killed. On 20 July 2010, Amit Jethwa, 32 year old RTI activist from Gir, was shot dead by two assailants on a motorbike outside the Ahmedabad High Court. Jethwa had used information obtained under the Right To Information Act 2005 to expose the network of illegal mining run by BJP MP Dinu Solanki in the Gir forest area. On 7 September 2010, the MP's nephew Shiva Solanki was arrested for Jethwa's murder. On 27 August 2010, Ramdas Ghadegaonkar was killed. Murder is usually the last step in a build up of harassment that takes many forms. Invention of cases and imprisonment is the most common form of police harassment, but it is not unlikely for the force to physically assault petitioners either. In other cases, intimidation is dealt out via less "legitimate' channels. From Jharkhand, Sumit Kumar Mahato, Convenor of the RTI Forum, talks about being manhandled by goons for seeking information about funds spent on the building of a road. Rolly Shivhare of Jaano Re Abhiyaan from MP says, "I filed an application to ask for the Midday Meal Scheme budget from the Panchayat and Rural Welfare Department. I received a threatening phone call asking what I would do with this information. The caller said he was the "Development Commissioner'. When the police traced the call, it was found that it had indeed come from his office, though the commissioner himself denied any knowledge of it." RTI activists have learnt through unfortunate examples not to take such initial threats lightly. Down south in Karnataka, Venkatesh, 32, had filed an application to expose the Bangalore Development Authorities' involvement in a land scam case. Despite receiving threats, he continued to pursue the case alone. In April 2009, Venkatesh's body was found near the divider of a highway. His death was registered as a traffic accident. The RTI Study Centre filed an RTI application for the post-mortem report which revealed that his head injury was caused by a blunt instrument. On investigation, four people were charged. They have all been linked to the contractors involved in the scam. Malay Bhattacharya, secretary of the West Bengal RTI Manch differentiates between the harassment in urban and rural areas, "In urban West Bengal, applicants are harassed by the police who come to their house and threaten them and their family members." In villages, he says, the authorities ensure that those filing RTI applications are boycotted socially. Patterns differ from state to state but every state can be mapped with such stories, each one more horrific than the other. From tiny tribal villages to the bustling lanes of Mumbai and Delhi; from farmers and lorry drivers to middle class professionals- cases of criminal harassment following RTI applications abound everywhere. The monitory and emotional fallouts in all cases are life altering for the petitioners and their families. In most cases, the petitioners that are attacked have already been through harassment, because of rigorous attempts to obstruct their application.
- Impact of Event
- 3
- Violation
- Intimidation and Threats
- Killing
- Rights Concerned
- Right to information
- Right to life
- Source
- Monitoring Status
- Not active
- Event Location
Latitude: 23.03879
Longitude: 72.56794
- Event Location
- Summary for Publications
In May, July and August 2010, three Right to Information (RTI) activists were murdered. On 26 May 2010, Datta Patil was killed. On 20 July 2010, Amit Jethwa, 32 year old RTI activist from Gir, was shot dead by two assailants on a motorbike outside the Ahmedabad High Court. Jethwa had used information obtained under the Right To Information Act 2005 to expose the network of illegal mining run by BJP MP Dinu Solanki in the Gir forest area. On 7 September 2010, the MP's nephew Shiva Solanki was arrested for Jethwa's murder. On 27 August 2010, Ramdas Ghadegaonkar was killed. Murder is usually the last step in a build up of harassment that takes many forms. Invention of cases and imprisonment is the most common form of police harassment, but it is not unlikely for the force to physically assault petitioners either. In other cases, intimidation is dealt out via less __�legitimate' channels. From Jharkhand, Sumit Kumar Mahato, Convenor of the RTI Forum, talks about being manhandled by goons for seeking information about funds spent on the building of a road. Rolly Shivhare of Jaano Re Abhiyaan from MP says, "I filed an application to ask for the Midday Meal Scheme budget from the Panchayat and Rural Welfare Department. I received a threatening phone call asking what I would do with this information. The caller said he was the __�Development Commissioner'. When the police traced the call, it was found that it had indeed come from his office, though the commissioner himself denied any knowledge of it." RTI activists have learnt through unfortunate examples not to take such initial threats lightly. Down south in Karnataka, Venkatesh, 32, had filed an application to expose the Bangalore Development Authorities' involvement in a land scam case. Despite receiving threats, he continued to pursue the case alone. In April 2009, Venkatesh's body was found near the divider of a highway. His death was registered as a traffic accident. The RTI Study Centre filed an RTI application for the post-mortem report which revealed that his head injury was caused by a blunt instrument. On investigation, four people were charged. They have all been linked to the contractors involved in the scam. Malay Bhattacharya, secretary of the West Bengal RTI Manch differentiates between the harassment in urban and rural areas, "In urban West Bengal, applicants are harassed by the police who come to their house and threaten them and their family members." In villages, he says, the authorities ensure that those filing RTI applications are boycotted socially. Patterns differ from state to state but every state can be mapped with such stories, each one more horrific than the other. From tiny tribal villages to the bustling lanes of Mumbai and Delhi; from farmers and lorry drivers to middle class professionals- cases of criminal harassment following RTI applications abound everywhere. The monitory and emotional fallouts in all cases are life altering for the petitioners and their families. In most cases, the petitioners that are attacked have already been through harassment, because of rigorous attempts to obstruct their application.